Oct 31, 2018 Infinite - 4/10 SSEP - 8/10 SSLP - 8.5/10 MMLP - 10/10 Devils Night - 6/10 TES - 7/10 8 Mile - 9/10 Encore - 5/10 Encore bonus disk- 8/10 D12 World - 3/10 Curtain Call (new songs) - 1/10 Re-Up - 6.5/10 Relapse - 5/10 Relapse bonus tracks - 8/10 Refill - 4/10 Recovery - 4/10 h---: The Sequel - 3/10 MMLP2 - 4/10 MMLP2 bonus disk - 9/10 Shady XV - 7/10 Southpaw - 8/10 Revival - 1/10 Kamikaze - 7/10 ———————— Total - 5.7/10 (132/230)
Nov 1, 2018 Here's my rating. He has been very consistent for me. I enjoy everything except Revival. Remember that replay value plays a huge role for me in deciding these ratings. MMLP (9.5/10) The Eminem Show (9.4/10) SSLP (9/10) Kamikaze (8.6/10) Recovery (8.1/10) (A pop rap album done right) MMLP2 (8/10) Relapse (8/10) Infinite (7.8/10) (This album is criminally underrated) Encore (7/10) (Dope album except that stretch from Puke to a--- Like That) Revival (5/10) (Some genuinely amazing highs, but way too many disgusting lows and average tracks)
Nov 1, 2018 7-9 somewhere in there I don’t think anyone’s discography is a 10 even jay nas pac and big had bad songs
Nov 1, 2018 The Slim Shady LP 7 The Marshall Mathers LP 10 The Eminem Show 10 Encore 10 Relapse 10 Recovery 7 MMLP2 8 (if the bonus tracks had made it to the main cd, it would be 10). Revival 10 Kamikaze 10 SO 9 for the whole discography.
Nov 1, 2018 8/10. There isn't many actual pure a--- albums. We just feel like there is, I feel, as Em fans, because we've been waiting for another classic since TES. He came out with 3 in a row, all greatness, which is very rare, and so anything less beyond that felt a---. The only truly trash albums I'd say are Encore and Revival. That's 2 out of 10. Then you got good but flawed albums like Infinite, Recovery & MMLP2. two great albums @ Relapse & Kam and three pure classics.
