Sep 14, 2020 It really is a b-----r. People will come around to the album just like Encore and Relapse.
Sep 14, 2020 Are you kidding? Is it in the Top 50? Did you start listening to Eminem last year? I can only make this list from 1999-2003 tracks
Sep 14, 2020 Nah, I started listening in 1999 and have been a huge fan since. Seen him live three times, front row twice, and he pointed at me and gave me an autographed doll live on stage, with Proof and D-12 autographs on the doll as well. That day he gave me the autograph was August 10, 2005. So no, I didn't start listening last year. Just to answer your question. Undoubtedly, 1999-2003 was his best period overall though.
Sep 14, 2020 So what the fact that they're new tracks means it can't be in the top 50? what you saying makes no sense
Sep 14, 2020 do you really think these new tracks are better than the other new track Stepping Stone? a very strange choice, considering your memory of D12.
Sep 14, 2020 For me it’s... 3. Stan 2. Going Through Changes 1. Deja vu I actually don’t really care about Stan; haven’t listened to it in years probably, but I respect its quality and impact and what it meant and still means for his career
Sep 14, 2020 My Top 50: Only Songs from his albums or solosongs, so no Renegade(would be Top 15 for sure) and no songs from the D12 Albums. Pretty tough to be honest. Sing For the Moment 8 Mile Road Stan Lose Yourself Rock Bottom Till I Collapse Soldier Marshall Mathers Say Goodbye to Hollywood The Way I am Murder Murder Criminal Still Don't Give a f--- k--- You Infinite Drug Ballad White America Rabbit Run Role Model The Ringer When I'm Gone Bully No Apologies Just Don't Give a f--- Believe Going Through Changes Brain Damage Deja Vu I'm Back We As Americans Square Dance Without Me As The World Turns Bad Influence Arose My Dad's Gone Crazy Stimulate The Real Slim Shady Stepping Stone Seduction Stay Wide Awake Like Toy Soldiers Guilty Conscience Love You More The Sauce Premonition Rap God Music Box Hellbound Who Knew
Sep 14, 2020 Respect my man on your list. I like it! I could never get into Music Box for whatever reason personally, but I really like the list. If you read one of my comments earlier, Who Knew, Square Dance, Stay Wide Awake and Role Model just BARELY missed my cut off of 50. Classics. I also like the appreciation for Love You More. Back when that leaked out in the day before Encore, I thought that had potential to be an original route for a lead single instead of the usual funny ones back in that era. NO DOUBT in my mind if that, We as Americans, and Bully didn't leak out....and they replaced the 3 worst songs off Encore....that album would be viewed so incredibly different. I'm saying it straight up. But good list man. I just made a post via request asking people to vote for their top 15 and I'll tally them all up. Copy and paste it in that too. But good list man. We have pretty similar taste it looks like.
