Nov 13, 2025 at 3:13 AM

I originally posted this in the album thread but think it deserves its own thread. Last year, Dopey Strange the famous Eminem leaker apparently leaked info about his “6th album” which revealed song names and dates they were recorded from the file data:




Here, we see the song “Ballin Uncontrollably” recorded as May 8, 2006. Proof was killed on April, 11 2006 and his funeral was held on April 19 2006.

This led me to the question; what the f--- was Eminem doing in the studio only 3 weeks after his best friend had been laid to rest, bragging about he he was balling, how he has candy painted rims and cars, and how he hits stores with wads of cash while people call him the candy man?

Very bad taste indeed. But then I realised something deeper in the lyrics.

Anybody familiar with Proofs death will know the whole situation started off over a game of pool. What does playing pool involve? Hitting balls.

Ballin uncontrollably
​

Let’s take a further look into the verse.

So dark I be lying if I said I ain't hit it at least nine of my friends
​

Is Eminem admitting his part in a potential murder here? We know by 06 Eminem had become pretty awful at rapping and Proof had actually almost gotten better.

Jealousy can be a very strong disease. I genuinely believe it to be strongly possible that Eminem himself secretly put out the hit that got his own so called best friend killed.

I know there’s more evidence potentially out there that could add to this theory about Eminem secretly bragging about it, so feel free to add it in the thread if you find any.

This man really is a disgusting nasty piece of s--- IMO.

 

Nov 13, 2025 at 6:53 AM

It's very plausible. Another clue may be found in him showing off his Proof tattoo and "P" chain a lot in pictures and videos back then, as if to boast: "I'm the man who killed Proof", with the name itself possibly being a taunt: "And I've covered my tracks so well that you'll never find proof".







I can't find it but I'm pretty sure I remember an interview from 2004 or 2005 where he said "keep your friends close but your enemies closer" (quoting from The Godfather). Very interesting considering this was when there was a lot of infighting within D12.

 

Nov 13, 2025 at 8:18 AM

I remember back in the day people thought it was an illuminati blood sacrifice. Lol

 

Nov 13, 2025 at 4:11 PM

This makes perfect sense. Also don’t forget the lyrics in that (very likely real) leaked verse: “if Dudey was here he’d need the Proof”

Im starting to wonder wether Eminem had something to do with Obie Trice getting shot in the head around the time too, and don’t even get me started on the tour bus “crash” that Em himself just conveniently wasn’t travelling on at the time.

 

Nov 13, 2025 at 4:27 PM

@John Lennons Ghost @Big Monkey I don't keep up with discords or the leak scene but do you guys think anything of these songs will ever see the light of day?

 

Nov 14, 2025 at 8:27 AM

So in all plausibility all his moralizing against Diddy for putting hits out on people is basically just guilt projection then. The more you peel back the onion layers of this guy's depravity and malignant narcissism the more tearful and painful they are to behold. The stories about him f---ing that 12 year old Swedish flicka and nearly beating his niece to death and threatening to sell her as kebab meat were bad enough but there's nothing worse than a snake slithering in the grass. Spineless. I guess that's why @Quarry and @Minato relate to him so much.

If they do I imagine it won't be for years and years down the line. Before SFTL3 leaked I had a private buy insider DM me here offering to let me in on some very promising info just to shut me up about the snippets being real, to which I agreed, and I even got to hear Antichrist a day before it went public (the day before, it was looking like songs were gonna get leaked prematurely anyway and the whole operation ruined due to "bad actors" but the hope was that the situation would somehow resolve itself). From what he told me it seems Dope Edit wasn't the only one in possession of all these songs and much (much) more, which were all expected to be purchased and leaked within a year or two. There's still a lot of interest in them but after the Strange fiasco everyone involved is too shook to make a move for the foreseeable future.