Feb 26, 2016 1 -- White America > My Name Is > k--- You Three great tracks. White America is the most intellectual, has the best bars and really nice delivery. MNI is the iconic song that introduced Slim Shady in all his glory. k--- You is very good too. Solid shock bars. 2 -- Stan > Guilty Conscience > Business Business is a nice song but Stan and Guilty Conscience are just quality storytelling. 3 -- Cleaning Out My Closet vs. Brain Damage vs. Who Knew All great. Einy meiny miney moe? 4 -- The Way I Am > Square Dance > If I Had TWIA has a great unique flow, passion throughout. It's a tough contest between the Bush sucks song and the blumpkin song. Ah well. 5 -- The Real Slim Shady > Soldier > '97 Bonnie & Clyde TRSS is not just a great hit with hilarious lyrics, but those multis are fire too. Soldier is just as hardcore as it gets. Bonnie is good storytelling tho. 6 -- Role Model vs. Remember Me vs. Say Goodbye Hollywood RM is exactly why I love SSLP. 7 -- I'm Back > My Fault > Drips I'm Back is just Em at his best shock-wise. My Fault is some funny storytelling. 8 -- Marshall Mathers > Without Me > c-m On Everybody Bars bars bars vs. great hit single. Ughh. 9 -- Sing For The Moment > Rock Bottom > Drug Ballad d---... All three of these songs go hard. I wish I could put em all at #1. 10 -- Just Don't Give A f--- > Superman > Amityville JDGAF is classic. Amityville is nice, horrorcore spooky. Superman has a nice sound to it; runs a little long tho. 11 -- Haile's Song vs. As The World Turns vs. b---- Please II Haile's song has good singing, good melody, strong lyrics, one of Em's most heartfelt stuff. 12 -- Kim > I'm Shady > When The Music Stops Love it or hate it, there's no song like Kim. 13 -- Bad Meets Evil > Say What You Say > Under The Influence SWYS is bars, but BME is more bars 14 -- Still Don't Give A f--- = Criminal = Till I Collapse All three songs are great. The only way to settle this is a tie. Done. 15 - The Kids > My Dad's Gone Crazy > Get You Mad TK was unique. MDGC has a goat 3rd verse. GYM is dope too. Results MMLP has 7 wins, TES has 4 wins, SSLP has 3 wins SSLP gets 30 pts , TES gets 31 pts, MMLP gets 32 pts Close race all around.
Feb 26, 2016 Stopped reading half way through but the concept is pretty good. Would prefer it to be over ALL albums though.
Feb 26, 2016 come on boy, there aren't many ways to do it 1 -- k--- You > White America > My Name Is 2 -- Stan > Guilty Conscience > Business 3 -- Brain Damage > Cleanin' Out My Closet > Who Knew 4 -- The Way I Am > Square Dance > If I Had 5 -- '97 Bonnie and Clyde > Soldier > The Real Slim Shady 6 -- Say Goodbye Hollywood > Role Model > Remember Me 7 -- I'm Back = My Fault > Drips 8 -- Marshall Mathers > Without Me > c-m On Everybody 9 -- Sing For The Moment = Rock Bottom = Drug Ballad 10 -- Just Don't Give A f--- > Superman > Amityville 11 -- Hailie's Song > As The World Turns > b---- Please II 12 -- Kim > I'm Shady > When The Music Stops 13 -- Bad Meets Evil > Under the Influence > Say What You Say 14 -- Criminal > Till I Collapse > SDGAF 15 - My Dad's Gone Crazy > The Kids > Get You Mad seems like 10-13 is the weakest part of each album
Feb 26, 2016 1 -- White America > k--- You > My Name Is 2 -- Stan > Business > Guilty Conscience 3 -- Who Knew > Brain Damage > Cleanin' Out My Closet 4 -- The Way I Am > Square Dance > If I Had 5 -- Soldier > '97 Bonnie and Clyde > The Real Slim Shady 6 -- Say Goodbye Hollywood > Role Model > Remember Me 7 -- I'm Back > My Fault > Drips 8 -- Marshall Mathers > c-m On Everybody > Without Me 9 -- Sing For The Moment > Rock Bottom > Drug Ballad 10 -- Superman > Just Don't Give A f--- > Amityville 11 -- As The World Turns > Hailie's Song > b---- Please II 12 -- Kim > I'm Shady > When The Music Stops 13 -- Bad Meets Evil > Under the Influence > Say What You Say 14 -- Criminal > SDGAF > Till I Collapse 15 - My Dad's Gone Crazy > The Kids > Get You Mad MMLP 7 TES 6 SSLP 2
Feb 26, 2016 My Name Is - k--- You - White America Guilty Conscience - Stan - Business Brain Damage - Who Knew? - Cleaning Out My Closet If I Had - The Way I Am - Square Dance '97 Bonnie & Clyde - The Real Slim Shady - Soldier Role Model - Remember Me? - Say Goodbye to Hollywood My Fault - I'm Back - Drips c-m On Everybody - Marshall Mathers - Without Me Rock Bottom - Drug Ballad - Sing For The Moment Just Don't Give A f--- - Amityville - Superman As The World Turns - b---- Please II - Hallie's Song I'm Shady - Kim - When The Music Stops Bad Meets Evil - Under the Influence - Say What You Say Still Don't Give a f--- - Criminal - Til I Collapse Get You Mad - The Kids - My Dad's Gone Crazy SSLP - 6 MMLP - 7 TES - 2
Feb 27, 2016 What an absolutely incredible list of songs man. Looking at all three choices for every track number and having so many positives for all 3 is very very rare.
Feb 27, 2016 I might do this format for my next s---t out. Absolutely. Cuz they're 3 dope works. And @Kace I also notice that pattern of 10-13 being the weakest. Typically, the beginning of albums are supposed to be strong, and the tail end are. And the iffy tracks are stuffed around the mid-late mark.
Feb 27, 2016 @Missile I agree with you. But..... Nowadays 'Em is focusing on mid parts to be stronger tho. Which is pretty sad for me cause I personally don't like the way he's managing tracks. For example, in recovery he placed most of the strong songs in between (GTC, NA, NL and so on) and same with MMLP2. I hope he gets back to his old days again
