Nov 9, 2020
https://youtu.be/MlfRhpOy6Yc
I think the first time I ever really cared about a game columnist was when Jeff Gerstman (I think I’m spelling that right) got fired from IGN for giving a low rating to a critically derided game that was paying for ad spots on their website. He went on to form Giant Bomb, which I still look to for reviews to this day.
For a while I didn’t “get” the appeal of Anthony Fantano. I just, sincerely, aggressively find his perspective on rap and the very qualities that might make a song appealing or interesting to not vibe with my own. But after spending way way too much free time watching longform video essays on dozens of games I’ve played and dozen I haven’t, I get the appeal of having a voice to anchor your critique and discussion around.
Especially as I’ve realized no matter how intelligent someone seems and how much you agree, it’s never good to take their word as gospel (seems obv but hey took me a while). I disliked Fantano partially for my own disagreements but partially for the annoying way his fans acted online and in my irl friend groups. I knew people that were essentially walking /mu/ charts that would just repeat fantanos words verbatim when asked about the specifics of any given project or artist, and in hindsight that’s probably what turned me off from him or his fan base as a whole.
All that to say that, as long as you’re taking a few grains of salt with it all, finding a specific author and engaging with the medium thru their lenses can be fascinating
-
(This ad goes away when signing up)
-
Nov 9, 2020
I like horror game walkthroughs when I’m smackedOrdinary Joel, skip, DKC and 2 others like this. -
Nov 11, 2020
Enez, skip, Ordinary Joel and 1 other person like this. -
Nov 9, 2020
Bruh I used to watch these all the time back in the day and after lockdown started I’ve been watching them more than ever. Some of my favorites are:
Ordinary Joel, Martha Stewart, Sign Language and 1 other person like this. -
Nov 16, 2020
skip, Ordinary Joel and Sign Language like this. -
Nov 11, 2020
skip, Ordinary Joel and Sign Language like this. -
Nov 11, 2020
Never watched them until @skip put me on. Videogamedunkey is hilarious!Enez, skip and Ordinary Joel like this. -
Nov 9, 2020
Ordinary Joel, skip and Sign Language like this. -
Nov 9, 2020
his videos on Kentucky route zero and the red dead series capture this the best imoOrdinary Joel, Thy and Sign Language like this. - Aug 4, 2025