Nov 28, 2015 RD > SSLP (RD is top 5 of all time) MMLP > Blueprint (and we all know who made the best verse in this album) TES > Black Album Recovery and American Gangster are both the same calibre So i guess Eminem wins
Nov 28, 2015 Rd >sslp Blueprint > mmlp (but pretty close imo) Black album > TES American Gangster >>>>>>>>> Recovery
Nov 28, 2015 To me, y'all already know. SSLP>RD MMLP>BP TES>TBA Recovery>AG But I guess objectively list should be like this. Reasonable Doubt> The Slim Shady LP ( Both considered undeniable classics but they couldn't be more different than each other. Hard to say which one is better.) The Marshall Mathers LP>The Blueprint ( Both are classics. But the fact that Eminem arguably rapped out Jay on Renegade kinda gives the MMLP the upper hand here.) The Eminem Show>The Black Album American Gangster>Recovery
Nov 28, 2015 SSLP<Reasonable Doubt MMLP>The Blueprint TES=The Black Album or TES slightly wins Recovery<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<American Gangster
Nov 28, 2015 Very easy choice for me The SSLP>>>>RD The MMLP>>>The Blueprint The Eminem Show (greatest album ever)>>>>>>The Black Album Recovery>>>>>>American Gangsters Jay Z's an execptional MC and Lyricist with Flow being his strong point but his albums bore me
Nov 28, 2015 why do you assume that just because people voted for Em they haven't heard anything else? ever heard of difference of opinion?
Nov 28, 2015 a better way to compare these would be having them all against each other instead of going one album vs another. like, SSLP may be better than reasonable doubt but maybe TBA is better than SSLP (just examples) it's like when you take two albums and compare the tracks just based on track number. I don't get it.
Nov 28, 2015 Yeah that's a horrible/nonsensical way to compare albums. You could compare, like a run of albums or RD/AG vs. SSLP/Recovery (compare their debuts and real comback after their botched comeback). But it doesn't make sense unless you look at them holistically.
