What is the most terrifying game you've ever played?

 

Silent Hill

 

Silent Hill 2 was great

 

this

or Resident Evil, shit used to f--k little me up

 

Any of the first three Silent Hill games, BioShock 1, Fatal Frame

 

Silent Hill 1-2
Fatal Frame 1-3
Resident Evil 1-3
Outlast
P.T. (Silent Hills Demo)
Amnesia : Dark Descent
White Night

 

great game

 

The only game that came a little close to actually scaring me (jumpscares don't count) is F.E.A.R. 2.
I think I was 11 when I was playing it, and that school level was creepy as shit. I couldn't even finish it.

 

Fallout 4

It's terrifying how they fucked this up

 

Not the scariest but hasn't been mentioned yet. Dead Space

 

SOMA
Outlast 1 (2 will probably be just as scary)
Dead Space 1/2 (not as scary as the above ones but still pretty creepy and they have their moments)

 

alien isolation can be scary at times

 

P.t is the only game that made me afraid to turn the corner. That and maybe Fatal Frame back in the day. Then it used to scare the shit out of me I don't know how well it holds up though I haven't played it since.